Friday 8 May 2020

The Beatles - For No One


1966 was Paul McCartney's annus mirabilis, and "Revolver" is its testament - the soulful "Got to get you into my life", the haunting "Eleanor Rigby", the sweeping ballad "Here There & Everywhere", but my favourite is the sublime "For No One". It is such a mature and sophisticated effort, that it is hard to conceive, it was barely three years since their first album.

Paul wrote it in a bathroom of a ski chalet in the Swiss Alps, during a trip with girlfriend Jane Asher. It is sorrowful charting of a break-up, and includes great economy of detail in just two minutes.

A superb opening line "Your day breaks, your mind aches", sets the scene in just six words  - a sense of pain and long nights of the soul. Followed by the poignant "You find that all the words of kindness linger on / When she no longer needs you" - a breakup and he is tormented by the memories.

Constructed like a poem, it is tempting to review every line. Not only does he convey his hurt, but also the girl's, who is crying not for him, but for the end of another relationship ("that should have lasted years").

He uses the same pattern at the start of each verse,  which describes the story ("You stay home, she goes out") and the minor details ("She wakes up, she makes up").  Brevity and fullness. Each word is carefully selected and honed, describing her love as "dead" is brutal.

McCartney has rarely sung better, slow and clipped. The backing echoes the more adventurous approach, with Paul playing bass, piano, and most importantly the baroque sound of the clavichord. Ringo supplies light drums, with the percussion of tambourine and maracas. Finally there is the beautiful French horn solo, from Alan Civil, pushed to its limits. A beautiful background to desolation.

For most artists "For No One" would be a career defining highlight, but for McCartney (and the Beatles) it is a "routine" album track, quickly written and recorded between tours. The wonder of the Beatles is not only their unassailable peaks, but the consistency and quantity.  


Hear Next -  The "Revolver" album is a always a great place to start.